1-1
2
3
6-1
4-1

Menu

View our cupcake collections below

If there is a particular flavor you would like from our menu that we do not have in-store, orders are accepted in a minimum of a half dozen per flavor ordered for regular and jumbo size cupcakes and minimum of a dozen per flavor ordered for mini cupcakes.

The Cupcakerie delivers to all locations in the Morgantown area for a $10 delivery fee.

The Original Collection

The Original Collection

VERY VANILLA

French vanilla cake, topped with creamy vanilla butter cream and finished with sprinkles

LOCO COCOA

Decadent chocolate cake filled with gooey chocolate, topped with luscious chocolate butter cream and sprinkled with dark chocolate shavings

RED CARPET RED VELVET

Classic southern red velvet cake, topped with our signature cream cheese frosting and sprinkled with luscious dark chocolate shavings

P’NUTTY FOR CHOCOLATE

Chocolate mousse cake filled with a chocolaty peanut butter surprise, topped with creamy peanut butter frosting and sprinkled with luscious dark chocolate shavings

A HARD DAY’S NIGHT

French vanilla cake, topped with luscious chocolate butter cream and sprinkled with rich dark chocolate shavings

A HARD NIGHT’S DAY

Decadent chocolate cake, topped with creamy vanilla butter cream and sprinkled with French dark chocolate shavings

TWIST AND SHOUT

Moist chocolate cake and French vanilla cake swirled together, topped with creamy vanilla butter cream and sprinkled with luxurious dark chocolate shavings

CREAM FILLED DELIGHT

French vanilla cake, filled with a gooey vanilla cream center and topped with smooth vanilla butter cream

CHOCOLATEY CARAMEL KISSES

Decadent chocolate cake filled with a chocolate caramel candy, topped with silky caramel butter cream and sprinkled with dark chocolate shavings

JOHN LEMMON

French vanilla cake accented with a splash of fresh lemon juice, topped with lemon-infused vanilla butter cream and sprinkled with yellow sugar pearls

THE YOKO ONO

Our newest lemon cupcake! Moist vanilla cake with “ono”-so-good lemon filling, finished with our signature lemon-infused butter cream

GIMME SOME MORE S’MORE

Moist chocolate cake, topped with creamy vanilla butter cream and sprinkled with delightful mini chocolate chips, fluffy mini marshmallows and sweet teddy bear shaped graham crackers

HOT FUDGE SUNDAE

Delicious chocolate cake, topped with a dollop of whipped vanilla butter cream, sprinkled with nut topping, drizzled with mini chocolate chops, and finished with a pretty little cherry on top

THE COOKIE MONSTER

Moist vanilla cake dotted with sweet chocolate chips, topped with creamy vanilla butter cream and sprinkled with delightful mini chocolate chips

THE PEANUT BUTTER COOKIE MONSTER

Moist vanilla cake dotted with sweet peanut butter chips, topped with creamy vanilla butter cream and sprinkled with delightful peanut butter chips

CHOCOLATE PEANUT BUTTER COOKIE MONSTER

Moist chocolate cake dotted with sweet peanut butter chips, topped with creamy chocolate butter cream, and sprinkled with delightful peanut butter chips

CHOCOLATE HAZELNUT-ELLA

Dark, delicious chocolate cake with a hazelnut filling, topped with smooth chocolate hazelnut icing and sprinkled with mini chocolate chips

SWEET ‘N SALTY

Savory caramel cake filled with a smooth caramel center, topped with creamy salted caramel butter cream and sprinkled with a pinch of sea salt

The Pink Collection

The Pink Collection

RASPBERRY PINK LEMONADE

Moist vanilla cake with a touch of fresh lemon, filled with a burst of fresh raspberries, topped with pretty pink lemonade butter cream and finished with sweet sugar pearls

NEAPOLITAN

Moist chocolate cake and French vanilla cake swirled together, topped with strawberry butter cream and sprinkled with luxurious dark chocolate shavings

RASPBERRY KISSED COCOA

Decadent chocolate cake with a sweet raspberry filling, topped with rich raspberry butter cream and sprinkled with pretty pink edible pearls

STRAWBERRY COVERED CHOCOLATES

Decadent chocolate cake, topped with fresh strawberry butter cream and sprinkled with rich dark chocolate shavings

BANANA SPLIT

Smooth banana bread cake dotted with chocolate chunks, topped with fresh strawberry butter cream, and sprinkled with mini chocolate chips

CHOCOLATE COVERED CHERRIES

Decadent chocolate cake, topped with sweet cherry butter cream, sprinkled with chocolate chips and pretty pink sugar pearls

STRAWBERRY FIELDS FOREVER

French vanilla cake swirled with a sweet strawberry puree, topped with creamy strawberry butter cream and sprinkled with pretty pink edible pearls

PRETTY IN PINK

Sweet cherry-vanilla cake with a touch of almond, filled with a delicious maraschino cherry and topped with pink cherry butter cream

ROCKIN’ RASPBERRY

Moist vanilla cake swirled with fresh raspberries, topped with sweet raspberry butter cream, and sprinkled with pretty pink sugar pearls

STRAWBERRY CREAM TRUFFLE

Moist chocolate cake filled with a cream vanilla center, topped with sweet strawberry butter cream and sprinkled with pretty sugar pearls

STRAWBERRY SHORTCAKE

French vanilla cake filled with a creamy vanilla center, topped with sweet strawberry butter cream and sprinkled with pretty sugar pearls

The Mountaineer Collection

The Mountaineer Collection

TAKE ME HOME ROCKY ROADS

Decadent chocolate mousse cake, topped with luscious chocolate butter cream and sprinkled with mini chocolate chips, fluffy mini marshmallows, chopped pecans and chopped walnuts

GOLD & BLUE-BERRY

Moist vanilla cake swirled with whole blueberries, topped with zesty lemon cream cheese frosting and dusted with cheery blue edible pearls

MOUNTAIN MAMA

Moist vanilla cake, filled with a burst of West Virginia apple butter, topped with apple butter infused butter cream and sprinkled with sweet cinnamon sugar

ALMOST HEAVEN APPLE PIE

Deliciously spiced apple pie cake, topped with light and fluffy butter cream, and sprinkled with sweet cinnamon sugar and graham cracker crumbs

The Candy Store Collection

The Candy Store Collection

MILK’S FAVORITE CUPCAKE

Dark, delicious chocolate cake with a cream filled chocolate cookie in the center, topped with smooth cream cheese icing and topped with yummy crushed cream filled chocolate cookies

SWEET SATISFACTION

Your favorite peanut, caramel, and chocolate candy bar has been made into a cupcake! Delicious chocolate mocha cake filled with gooey chocolate and caramel, topped with creamy caramel butter cream, sprinkled with sweet chocolate shavings, and finished with a peanut on top

CHOCOLATY M-N-M

Sweet dark chocolate cake dotted with candy coated chocolates, topped with creamy chocolate butter cream and sprinkled with your favorite candy coated chocolates

COOKIES ‘N CREAM

Moist vanilla cake dotted with cream filled chocolate cookies, filled with a smooth creamy center, topped with vanilla butter cream and sprinkled with yummy crushed cream filled chocolate cookies

COTTON CANDY

Moist vanilla cake infused with cotton candy flavor, topped with fluffy cotton candy butter cream

The “21” Collection

The “21” Collection

“PINA COLADA” CUPCAKE

If you like Pina Coladas…you are sure to like this sweet pineapple-filled coconut cake, topped with creamy coconut icing, and sprinkled with toasted coconut and macadamia nuts

COCOA MIMOSA

Decadent chocolate mousse cake accented with a splash of fresh orange, topped with citrusy orange-infused vanilla butter cream and sprinkled with rich dark chocolate shavings

CINCO DE MAYO “MARGARITA”

It’s five o’clock somewhere! Sit back, relax, and enjoy your favorite (non-alcoholic) frozen beverage in cupcake form! This sweet lime cupcake is topped with a citrusy lime butter cream and sprinkled with tiny bits of Mediterranean sea salt

PEACH MARGARITA

Moist vanilla cake swirled with sweet peaches and tangy tequila, topped with smooth peach butter cream, and sprinkled with sea salt

STRAWBERRY MARGARITA

Moist vanilla cake swirled with sweet strawberries and tangy tequila, topped with smooth strawberry butter cream, and sprinkled with sea salt

MUDSLIDE

Dark chocolate cake infused with coffee liquor, topped with Irish cream and coffee liquor butter cream, white sugar pearls, and a chocolate drizzle

The Fruity Collection

The Fruity Collection

IT’S KEY LIME TIME!

French vanilla cake accented with a splash of fresh lime juice, topped with a citrusy lime-infused vanilla butter cream

ORANGE CREAMSICLE

French vanilla cake filled with a smooth cream filling, topped with fresh orange scented frosting

COCONUT PARADISE

French vanilla cake accented with a taste of almond, topped with our signature cream cheese frosting and sprinkled with toasted sweet coconut

THE HUMDINGER

A delightful twist on classic hummingbird cake! Sweet yellow cake infused with pineapple and banana, topped with our signature cream cheese icing, and sprinkled with freshly chopped pecans

THE ELVIS

Smooth banana bread cake dotted with chocolate chunks, topped with cream peanut butter icing and sprinkled with dark chocolate shavings

MOCHA MONKEY

Smooth banana bread cake dotted with chocolate chunks, topped with milky chocolate butter cream and sprinkled with mini chocolate chips

ALMOND COCONUT RAZZLE DAZZLE

French vanilla cake accented with shredded coconut, fresh raspberries, and a taste of almond, topped with delicious cream cheese frosting, and sprinkled with toasted sweet coconut

LEMON LIME

French vanilla cake accented with zesty fresh lemon juice, topped with sweet and citrusy lime butter cream, and sprinkled with sweet sugar pearls

PEACHES ‘N CREAM

Moist vanilla cake swirled with fresh peach slices, topped with smooth butter cream, and sprinkled with sweet cinnamon sugar and nutmeg

STRAWBERRY LIME

French vanilla cake swirled with fresh strawberry puree, topped with zesty lime butter cream and sprinkled with pretty sugar pearls

The Decadent Dessert Collection

The Decadent Dessert Collection

BLACK FOREST CUPCAKE

Dark, delicious chocolate cake with a sweet cherry filling, topped with smooth chocolate icing, mini chocolate chips, a dollop of butter cream, and a pretty little cherry on top

CHOCOLATE TURTLE

Decadent chocolate cake, filled with sweet caramel, topped with smooth caramel butter cream, and sprinkled with fresh chopped pecans

CHOCOLATE ECLAIR

French vanilla cake filled with a gooey cream center and topped with luscious chocolate butter cream

I LOVE GERMAN-Y CHOCOLATE

Savory moist German chocolate cake, topped with decadent coconut-pecan frosting

TO-DIE-FOR TIRAMISU

Moist ladyfinger-like cake, with a sweet cream filling, topped with rich chocolate coffee butter cream, and sprinkled with dark chocolate shavings

HOLY CANNOLI!!!

The classic Italian favorite dessert transformed into a cupcake, topped with cream cannoli filling, and sprinkled with crushed pistachios and luscious dark chocolate chips

The Cozy Collection

The Cozy Collection

CARAMEL APPLE

Moist vanilla cake swirled with sweet caramel and fresh apples, topped with smooth caramel butter cream, and drizzled with caramel

SERGEANT PEPPERMINT CHOCOLATE

Decadent chocolate cake accented with a hint of fresh mint, topped with minty green butter cream and sprinkled with mini chocolate chips

24 KARAT CAKE

Luxurious carrot cake dotted with crunchy walnuts and fresh California raisins, topped with our signature cream cheese frosting, and sprinkled with crushed walnuts

COCOA MOCHA

Decadent chocolate cake infused with espresso, topped with chocolate butter cream and sprinkled with espresso powder

SNICKERDOODLE

Your favorite cinnamon cookie in cupcake form! Topped with luscious cinnamon butter cream and dusted with sweet cinnamon sugar

CHAI ME

Delicious spice cake, topped with smooth vanilla butter cream and sprinkled with sweet cinnamon sugar

PUMPKIN PIE

Deliciously spiced pumpkin pie cake, topped with smooth cream cheese and sprinkled with sweet cinnamon sugar

The Brunch Collection

The Brunch Collection

BREAKFAST IN YOUR HAND

Dark chocolate cake with bits of fresh apple wood smoked bacon swirled in, topped with sweet maple butter cream and topped with bits of delicious bacon

FRENCH TOAST

Your favorite brunch delight in a cupcake! Moist vanilla cinnamon cake, topped with delicious maple butter cream, and sprinkled with sweet cinnamon sugar

GLORIA’S COFFEE CAKE

There’s no better way to start your day than with a cup of fresh brewed coffee cake! Covered with smooth vanilla butter cream, and sprinkled with sweet cinnamon sugar

LEMON POPPYSEED

Zesty and sweet lemon cake, topped with citrusy lemon cream cheese and sprinkled with poppy seeds